In the ongoing final saga of One Piece set on Egghead Island, enthusiasts have engaged in discussions contemplating the potential outcomes if Luffy had never encountered his crew in the series.
The enduring legacy of One Piece, with its extensive narrative encompassing over 1,000 anime episodes, might appear daunting for newcomers. However, seasoned fans unanimously assert that the journey is well worth it, extending nearly three decades across the vast Grand Line.
As the narrative of One Piece unfolds, maintaining consistency requires aligning various details and plot points. Fans, drawing inspiration from Marvel’s “What If…?” series, delve into an in-depth exploration of the hypothetical scenario wherein Luffy never crossed paths with his companions.
One Piece Fans Discuss If Luffy Went With Shanks
On the One Piece subreddit, user u/Crimoro introduces a straightforward scenario that carries unforeseen consequences: “What if Shanks opted to take Luffy along instead of Luffy embarking on his own journey?”
The familiar narrative unfolds as fans recall the tale of a young Luffy aspiring to accompany Shanks on his adventure. However, Luffy realizes his lack of readiness after consuming the Gum-Gum Devil Fruit, an event marked by Shanks sacrificing his arm to save the boy from drowning.
Enthusiasts on the subreddit enthusiastically contribute their perspectives on this intriguing “What If?” scenario, and some present a rather somber prediction for the fate of the Straw Hat crew had Luffy never crossed paths with them. For instance, u/hana-hana-no-mi speculates that many crew members would meet untimely deaths.
The grim reality surfaces: Zoro wouldn’t have Luffy to rescue him from execution, Usopp would succumb to Kuro’s actions, and Nami would remain under Arlong’s control after he deceives her; the bleak forecast continues. The consensus is that the crew’s circumstances would be dire if Luffy had embarked on the sea journey with Shanks.
Fans inject humor into the discussion, suggesting that a young Luffy on board Shanks’ crew would likely be more trouble than he’s worth. User u/ThatOneLuffy humorously quips that “Shanks would end up losing his other arm,” with others highlighting the potential power dynamic in the grand scheme of the story with Luffy under Shanks.
Alternative speculations emerge, proposing that Luffy might eventually depart from Shanks’ crew to establish his own. Given Luffy’s childhood dream of becoming the king of the pirates, this hypothesis finds support among fans. Reference to Pirate King Gol D. Roger’s impact on Shanks in One Piece Chapter 968 adds a layer of complexity to the narrative, with fans anticipating further clarification in the storyline.
While awaiting potential revelations in the story regarding the Shanks and Roger connection, fans can find solace in the current reality where Luffy encountered his friends, averting a disastrous fate for most of them, and forming the beloved Straw Hat crew.
Suggested Read: What is a Buster Call in One Piece?
